How Understanding Causal Relations Counts in Criticizing Arguments Against Anthropogenic Global Climate Change

Open access
Date
2014-06-01Type
- Journal Article
ETH Bibliography
yes
Altmetrics
Abstract
There is a broad range of arguments against anthropogenic global climate change (AGCC) brought forward by climate sceptics. It is important to examine those through different perspectives. This paper provides a philosophical analysis of how causal relations are conceived in this debate. The analysis focuses on those sceptics' arguments that do not share properties of causal relations, which are otherwise typical in science. Causal relations (a) are generic relations between event types, (b) they include feedback, (c) they account for complex causes, and (d) they are restricted to a limited number of selected factors, which are defined as event types. A two-step approach was used in structuring this analysis. First, we show that these properties are at the core of natural sciences understanding of causation and how they can be explicated on the basis of the regularity theory of causation. These properties are crucial in the argument for AGCC as depicted in the Fourth Assessment Report issued by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Therefore, IPCC's causal claim is conditional on this understanding of causal relations and, more specifically, the set of examined factors and their definitions. Second, we show how a different understanding of each of these features is a source of disagreement on AGCC by distinguishing between different types of objections, which are illustrated by examples taken from various sources including the Internet. So, pointing out different understandings of causal relations is an appropriate way of criticising this kind of scepticism regarding AGCC. Show more
Permanent link
https://doi.org/10.3929/ethz-b-000091276Publication status
publishedExternal links
Journal / series
Meteorologische ZeitschriftVolume
Pages / Article No.
Publisher
SchweizerbartSubject
anthropgenic climate change; Climate sceptics; Causal relationsOrganisational unit
03728 - Engel, Stefanie (ehemalig)
08804 - Environmental Philosophy
More
Show all metadata
ETH Bibliography
yes
Altmetrics