Emerging and Disruptive Technologies Transform, but Do Not Lift, the Fog of War – Evidence from Russia's War on Ukraine
OPEN ACCESS
Loading...
Author / Producer
Date
2024
Publication Type
Conference Paper
ETH Bibliography
yes
Citations
Altmetric
OPEN ACCESS
Data
Abstract
In this working paper, we ask how have new technologies affected the Clausewitzian fog of war? We leverage examples from Russia’s ongoing full-scale invasion of Ukraine to address this research question. The evidence includes both “high-tech” systems like nuclear-capable hypersonic weapons and “low-tech” systems like cheap commercially available drones and affordable open-source intelligence (OSINT) technology. In the case of the former, we find that Russian threats and propaganda created myths surrounding weapons with unclear military applications. Regarding the latter, media and pundit claims were sensational as these systems changed combat dynamics without delivering revolutionary effects. Both cases point to pronounced gaps between expectations about performance and battlefield realities. Emerging weapon technologies have therefore failed to provide clarity about the balance of forces and conditions on the ground––two pathways to reducing the fog of war. In land warfare, history has long shown that new technologies are rarely determinative of victory or defeat. Making claims to the contrary only contributes to the fog of war and necessitates new strategies to counter the hype surrounding exaggerated expectations about weapons.
Permanent link
Publication status
published
External links
Editor
Book title
Russia’s War Against Ukraine – Complexity of Contemporary Clausewitzian War
Journal / series
Volume
2024/33
Pages / Article No.
146 - 161
Publisher
National Defence University, Department of Warfare
Event
6th Annual Russia Seminar 2024
Edition / version
Methods
Software
Geographic location
Date collected
Date created
Subject
Russia-Ukraine War; Emerging technologies; Drone (UAV); satellite data; Hypersonic weapons; foreign policy; warfare; international relations; international security; Russia; Ukraine; Defence industry; innovation; OSINT; Artificial intelligence (AI)
Organisational unit
03515 - Wenger, Andreas / Wenger, Andreas